Look beyond the polished career story
Experienced executives are usually comfortable explaining past achievements. Those accounts matter, but they can leave hiring leaders unsure how much of the outcome came from the candidate’s judgement, the team around them or favourable conditions. A live case discussion adds another kind of evidence: how someone thinks through an unfamiliar problem.
The aim is not to catch candidates out or find the person who reaches a preferred answer fastest. It is to explore how they frame a decision, identify missing information and balance competing priorities. Candidates should know that purpose before the interview.
Build a decision, not a presentation assignment
Use a short, fictional scenario that reflects the demands of the role without asking candidates to solve a current business problem for free. For an operations leader, the case might involve a proposed site consolidation with uncertain savings, service risks and limited management capacity. Keep the briefing brief enough to read during the session.
Include a clear decision, a few relevant facts and genuine gaps. Ask: ‘What would you recommend at this stage, and what would you need to establish before committing?’ Avoid specialist knowledge that is not essential to the role. If the exercise depends on unfamiliar terminology or hidden organisational context, it may test insider knowledge rather than judgement.
Give every candidate the same core brief, preparation time and starting questions. Explain the format in advance and offer reasonable adjustments. Unless slide-making is itself relevant to the job, a conversation is usually more revealing than a polished deck.
Probe the reasoning before changing the facts
Start by asking candidates to describe the problem in their own words. Notice whether they distinguish facts from assumptions, identify who carries the risk and ask questions that could change the decision. A long list of information requests is not necessarily a sign of depth; the stronger signal is knowing which unknowns matter most.
Then explore the trade-offs. Useful prompts include: ‘What are you choosing not to optimise?’, ‘Which part of this decision is reversible?’ and ‘What evidence would make you change your recommendation?’ These questions make it harder to rely on general leadership language.
Once the candidate has formed an initial view, introduce one new fact using the same planned update for everyone. Perhaps the expected savings are less certain, or a key dependency will take longer than assumed. Look for a reasoned adjustment, not automatic agreement with the interviewer.
Score judgement, not resemblance
Agree assessment criteria before meeting candidates. These might cover problem definition, prioritisation, treatment of uncertainty, stakeholder awareness and the practicality of the next step. Interviewers should record specific evidence and score independently before discussing their conclusions.
Do not confuse confidence with sound judgement, or hesitation with weakness. A candidate who pauses to clarify a critical assumption may be doing better work than one who delivers an immediate answer. Equally, asking for more data indefinitely can become a way to avoid taking a position.
For candidates, the best approach is to make the reasoning visible: state your assumptions, explain your provisional recommendation and name the conditions that would change it. For hiring leaders, treat the exercise as one source of evidence alongside career history, structured interviews and references—not as a verdict on its own.
How Valiant helps
Valiant Search Groups helps hiring leaders shape executive interviews around the decisions a role will require. We support clear assessment criteria and focused discussions, while helping candidates understand the process so they can demonstrate their judgement without unnecessary preparation work.

