A group appointment is still a board appointment
A subsidiary directorship can look like a straightforward addition to an executive role. The parent sets the strategy, central functions provide support and the board approves decisions already discussed elsewhere. That arrangement becomes fragile when the interests of the group and the needs of the subsidiary diverge.
A proposed dividend, intercompany loan or restructuring can expose the difference. Directors need to understand their responsibilities to the entity they serve, rather than assume that group approval settles the matter. The precise duties depend on the jurisdiction and circumstances, but the recruitment question is consistent: will this person exercise judgement when a parent-company instruction needs scrutiny?
Define the authority before choosing the director
Hiring leaders should establish what the subsidiary board actually decides. Distinguish decisions reserved for the parent as shareholder, matters delegated to management and matters requiring subsidiary board approval. If those boundaries exist only in people's heads, even an experienced appointee will struggle to work effectively.
The appointment brief should also explain how directors obtain information, access independent advice and escalate concerns. Test the arrangements with a practical scenario: if the board cannot support a proposed transfer of funds, who hears the concern, what evidence is required and can the decision be paused? An unclear answer points to a governance problem that recruitment alone cannot solve.
Assess challenge where loyalties overlap
Subsidiary directors may also be employees of the parent, colleagues of the group chief executive or leaders whose budgets depend on central approval. These relationships do not automatically prevent effective oversight, but they make the ability to challenge constructively particularly important.
Ask candidates for examples of questioning a decision backed by a senior sponsor. Explore how they established the facts, separated competing responsibilities and recorded the outcome. A useful interview exercise is a parent request for an urgent dividend supported by incomplete cash-flow information. Strong candidates should identify what they need to know, who should advise and what would prevent approval—not simply promise to be courageous.
Candidates should examine how the board works in practice
Before accepting, candidates should ask about board papers, meeting time, access to local management and the handling of conflicts. Subject to appropriate confidentiality arrangements, recent agendas and sample papers can help reveal whether the board considers substantive choices or mainly records decisions made elsewhere.
Candidates should also clarify the time commitment beyond scheduled meetings, relevant training, indemnities and directors' and officers' insurance. Where responsibilities span jurisdictions or regulated activities, specialist advice may be necessary. Reluctance to answer reasonable questions about the role is itself useful information: accountability should come with the information and access needed to discharge it.
How Valiant helps
Valiant Search Groups helps hiring leaders turn governance requirements into clear appointment briefs and assess candidates for judgement, constructive challenge and relevant experience. We help senior candidates examine the expectations and practical demands of a board role, so both sides can make a better-informed decision.

