Valiant Search Groups emblem

Talent strategy · 8 Nov 2026 · 3 min read

Build succession depth beyond the obvious deputy

A stronger succession plan tests readiness, widens the field and gives potential leaders meaningful experience before a vacancy appears.

A deputy is not automatically a successor

The person closest to an executive often becomes the default successor. They know the business, attend the right meetings and provide continuity when the leader is away. Those are useful strengths, but they do not establish readiness for the whole role.

A deputy may excel at delivery while having limited experience of setting direction, allocating capital or handling board scrutiny. Equally, a strong potential successor may sit elsewhere in the organisation, outside the current leader’s immediate team. Succession planning should identify credible options, not simply confirm the reporting line.

Define what the next leader must be able to do

Start with the decisions and responsibilities that make the role demanding. Avoid building a profile around the incumbent’s personality or career history. Instead, identify the situations a successor must handle: resolving competing investment priorities, leading across markets, managing regulatory relationships or challenging a long-established operating model.

Separate emergency cover from permanent succession. Someone who can keep operations stable for three months may not be the right person to lead the function for several years. Both needs deserve a plan, but treating them as interchangeable creates false confidence.

For each potential successor, record evidence of relevant capability, gaps that matter and the experience needed to close them. Labels such as ‘ready soon’ are only useful when they come with a clear explanation.

Give people responsibility that reveals readiness

Development should involve consequential work, not just greater visibility. Asking a potential successor to observe a board meeting is different from asking them to present a recommendation, defend its assumptions and take responsibility for the outcome.

Useful assignments might include leading a cross-functional investment decision, taking temporary responsibility for another business unit or resolving a difficult customer issue. Set explicit decision rights and provide support without allowing the incumbent to quietly make every important call.

Review the assignment against agreed criteria. Did the individual seek challenge, make trade-offs and bring others with them? A successful outcome matters, but so does the quality of the decisions behind it. Senior candidates should ask for this kind of feedback rather than relying on general assurances about their potential.

Keep the process honest without creating a contest

Avoid presenting succession as a private promise or a public race. A promise can become impossible to honour if the role changes; a race can encourage talented colleagues to compete rather than collaborate. Be clear that development creates options, not a guaranteed appointment.

Tell individuals what they are being developed towards, where the gaps remain and when progress will be reviewed. Give them room to state their own ambitions. Not every capable executive wants the travel, scrutiny or broader accountability attached to the next role.

Use external market insight to challenge internal assumptions, not to undermine internal candidates. An external comparison can reveal missing experience or confirm that an internal option is strong. Keep sensitive information tightly controlled and distinguish exploratory market research from an active search.

How Valiant helps

Valiant Search Groups helps hiring leaders define executive requirements, assess the external talent market and build a search approach alongside internal succession planning. The aim is a better-informed appointment decision, with clear expectations and a respectful process for candidates.

← All insights

Ready when you are

Let's talk about the leader you need.

Book a call →